Islamabad is currently witnessing one of its largest and most controversial tree-removal campaigns, aimed primarily at eliminating Paper Mulberry, locally known as wild mulberry, because of its association with severe seasonal pollen allergies.
The campaign has become the subject of intense public, environmental and judicial debate.
The Islamabad High Court initially restrained the Capital Development Authority from further tree cutting on January 15, 2026, and later extended the injunction until February 13 while seeking detailed responses from the CDA and other relevant authorities.
Environmental groups and citizens have raised concerns that old and indigenous trees may also have been affected during the clearing operations. The CDA, however, maintains that the organised eradication programme specifically targeted Paper Mulberry, while other species were marked and preserved. The authority also told the court that the operation had been carried out under directives from the Prime Minister’s Office.
According to official government figures released in January 2026, approximately 80,000 Paper Mulberry trees had been identified for removal across Islamabad, of which 29,115 had already been removed.
The largest removal operations were carried out in F-9 Park, where 12,800 trees were removed, and Shakarparian, where 8,700 were removed.
In addition, thousands of trees were cleared from areas including G-10, G-11, F-10, F-11, D-12 and along Srinagar Highway, as well as G-8, G-9, F-8, H-8 and H-9.
The government’s position is that Paper Mulberry is the principal contributor to Islamabad’s severe pollen problem.
Pakistan Meteorological Department data identifies Paper Mulberry as by far the dominant source of pollen during Islamabad’s spring season, while scientific research has also found an association between Paper Mulberry pollen concentrations and respiratory allergies and asthma exacerbations.
The government has therefore adopted a three-for-one replacement policy, under which three indigenous or environmentally suitable trees are to be planted for every Paper Mulberry removed.
Official figures stated that more than 40,000 replacement trees had already been planted, while the government planned to increase the total to approximately 90,000 by April 2026.
Species identified in official briefings include Kachnar, Amaltas, Desi Toot and Pilkan. In separate restoration work at Shakarparian, officials also referred to species including Chir Pine, Arjun and other locally suitable trees.
What Actually Makes a Tree Environmentally Suitable?
A tree should not be considered environmentally beneficial merely because it is green.
Its value depends on how well it fits the local climate, ecosystem, human health requirements and biodiversity.
Paper Mulberry is a non-native invasive species in Islamabad and has become strongly associated with the city’s pollen crisis. Scientific research conducted in Islamabad has identified alternatives such as Kachnar and Chir Pine as potentially more suitable from environmental and economic perspectives.
Kachnar and Amaltas are generally regarded as more appropriate urban planting choices because their pollination characteristics differ significantly from the highly airborne pollen produced by male Paper Mulberry trees.
They also provide flowers, habitat and food resources that can support pollinating insects and urban biodiversity.
Desi Toot often creates confusion among citizens because people naturally ask why one type of mulberry is being removed while another is being planted.
The important distinction is that Paper Mulberry, Broussonetia papyrifera, is a different species, introduced into Islamabad and now considered invasive, whereas native or locally established mulberry species have different ecological and pollen characteristics.
Chir Pine, or Pinus roxburghii, is naturally associated with the wider Margalla and Himalayan foothill environment and can contribute to long-term tree cover.
However, it must be planted carefully because dry pine litter can contribute to fire risk in suitable conditions, particularly in the Margalla Hills.
The larger environmental advantage of replacing a dominant invasive species with a diverse mixture of locally suitable trees lies in biodiversity.
Planting only one species over very large areas creates a form of monoculture, which can make an urban ecosystem more vulnerable to disease, pests and environmental stress.
A mixed plantation can make the system more resilient.
This is why the government’s 3:1 replacement policy can potentially become environmentally beneficial — but only if the replacement trees survive, mature and are properly maintained.
The Real Question: What Happens to Islamabad’s Green Cover in the Meantime?
This is where the most important environmental question arises.
If tens of thousands of mature trees are removed within a relatively short period, what happens to shade, local temperature regulation, humidity, airflow, wildlife habitat and the overall urban ecosystem before the replacement trees mature?
Urban trees provide cooling through both shade and transpiration, so removing mature canopy can temporarily reduce those benefits.
However, it would be scientifically unsafe to state that the removal will automatically increase temperature by exactly one or two degrees Celsius in Islamabad, because the local effect depends on canopy density, surface materials, wind, location and the scale of removal.
What can reasonably be said is that substantial loss of mature tree canopy can increase local heat exposure until replacement vegetation develops sufficient canopy. Research internationally confirms the important role of urban trees in reducing heat and providing shade.
This creates what can be described as a temporary Green Gap.
Young saplings cannot immediately replace the environmental functions of mature trees.
Even when three new trees are planted for every tree removed, the environmental benefit depends on their survival rate, growth, canopy development and long-term maintenance.
Different species also grow at different rates.
Some may begin providing useful shade within a few years, while slower-growing species can take considerably longer to develop a mature canopy.
For this reason, it would be premature to guarantee that Islamabad will be cooler or completely free of pollen allergy by 2030.
A more defensible conclusion is that, if the replacement programme is successfully implemented and maintained, Islamabad could gradually reduce its dependence on allergenic Paper Mulberry while rebuilding a more diverse and resilient urban tree canopy.
The government itself has projected a substantial reduction in pollen-related illness from the programme, but that remains an official projection rather than a guaranteed outcome.
Citizens Also Have a Role in Filling the Green Gap
Because replacement trees require time to mature, Urban Plantation at household and neighbourhood level can help reduce the temporary loss of canopy.
Residents of Islamabad can contribute by planting suitable, low-allergen and climate-appropriate trees in gardens, streets and neighbourhood open spaces, provided plantation is coordinated with local authorities and does not interfere with utilities or road safety.
Kachnar and Amaltas can be useful choices for suitable residential spaces, while species such as Arjun, Jamun and other locally appropriate shade trees may be considered for larger streets and open areas.
The most important principle is not simply to plant as many trees as possible.
It is to plant the right species, in the right location, with proper spacing, watering and long-term care.
Newly planted trees require particular attention during their first few years while root systems become established.
The Islamabad debate therefore should not be reduced to a simple choice between “cut the trees” or “do not cut the trees.”
Paper Mulberry presents a genuine public-health problem in the capital, and official as well as scientific evidence supports its role in severe pollen allergy.
At the same time, removing tens of thousands of mature trees creates legitimate concerns about biodiversity, urban heat and the temporary loss of green cover.
The real test of the policy will therefore be whether the government can demonstrate that only the intended invasive species are being removed, replacement plantation is scientifically planned, planted trees actually survive, and Islamabad ultimately gains more healthy and diverse tree canopy than it loses.