Overseas Pakistanis and retired pensioners are often among those most exposed to losses in such schemes.
In recent years, a new phrase has become increasingly common in Pakistan’s real estate market: “Guaranteed Return” or “Cashback Scheme.”
Some well known developers in the country have adopted a new method of raising money from the market by offering investors annual returns ranging from 12% to 18% on units in building projects.
At first glance, these promises appear highly attractive. However, the actual dynamics of Pakistan’s real estate market tell a very different story.
The reality is that the actual yield on commercial property in Pakistan generally does not exceed 7% to 8%, while the yield on residential property usually remains around 5% to 6%.
This raises a basic question: how can an incomplete building with no tenant generate a 12%, 15% or 18% Guaranteed Return?
1. Mixed Use Projects
For example, a mixed use development may include retail shops, office spaces and residential apartments. The developer may promise a 15% annual guaranteed cashback.
This means that if a buyer purchases a unit, the company promises to pay an annual return of 15% for a specified period, whether or not the unit is actually rented out.
2. Hotel Suite or Retail Only Model
A hotel suite model, or a purely commercial Retail Only project, can be an even more risky form of investment.
In this model, a buyer is sold a specific unit, such as a shop or hotel suite, and the developer says that the company itself will operate the unit, for example as a hotel room or showroom, and pay the buyer a monthly or annual return of 10% to 20%.
In practice, the buyer effectively becomes an investor rather than simply a property owner, and the return may continue only as long as new units keep selling or sufficient project funds remain available.
3. Serviced Apartment or Shared Ownership Model
Under this model, a single apartment may be divided among several buyers.
Each buyer is promised either the right to use the property for a certain period or to receive a specified return.
However, because ownership is shared and the project remains under the operational control of the developer, buyers may eventually find themselves receiving neither the promised return nor possession of the property, leaving only the original promises behind.
In such projects, the return may not come from actual rental income but from money received from new buyers.
This creates what can become a Ponzi style cash flow model, which continues only as long as new bookings keep coming in.
As soon as new bookings slow down or stop, the entire structure can begin to collapse like a Domino Effect.
First, return payments stop. Then construction begins to face delays. Eventually, offices may close altogether.
According to Pakistani law, a private company cannot collect money from the public while promising a Guaranteed Profit unless it has the required approval from the SECP.
The SECP Act 1997 and Companies Act 2017 treat such promises as unlawful and unsafe where the required regulatory approval is not in place.
This checklist can help protect your investment from fraud and financial loss.