Home
Image
Maryam Nawaz Sharif, Okra and Lentils, and the Philosophy of Taste
From international recognition in Muscat for the Apni Chhat, Apna Ghar programme to a family home in Hasan Abdal
 
Zameeni Haqaiq | A column by Syed Shayan
 
The Apni Chhat, Apna Ghar programme, launched by Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif, has drawn considerable attention in recent weeks. The programme offers interest free loans to families on low incomes so they can build homes of their own. That is a commendable initiative. In Pakistan, where millions of families spend a lifetime dreaming of a roof of their own, the chance to build a home is no small thing.
The programme has also received international recognition. On 5 October, Maryam Nawaz Sharif received the 2026 Scroll of Honour Award from the United Nations Human Settlements Programme at a ceremony in Muscat. The award recognised the Apni Chhat, Apna Ghar programme. It is heartening to see a housing initiative from a Pakistani province earn such recognition abroad.
 
A few days ago, far from the award ceremony in Muscat, a visit to a family home in Hasan Abdal caught the public imagination. A video of the visit has circulated widely on social media and drawn a range of reactions.
On 3 November, Maryam Nawaz Sharif shared a video on X showing her sitting down to a meal with a family in Hasan Abdal. Retired Havildar Aitbar Shah had built the house on his own plot with a loan of 1.5 million rupees under the programme.
 
The Chief Minister congratulated the family on their new home, spent time with them and stayed for a home cooked meal.
According to a report published by the Associated Press of Pakistan on 4 November 2026, Maryam Nawaz Sharif told her hosts that she would like to join them for lunch. The family served freshly cooked okra and lentils, which she ate with evident enjoyment. She later offered a prayer for her hosts in a post on X. Her words, translated from Urdu, read:
 
“May Allah always keep them happy and their home full of life. I can hardly remember eating more delicious okra and lentils.”
Her words brought to mind a passage I would like to share with my regular readers. In his book Hiero, the ancient Greek writer Xenophon imagines a conversation between Hiero, the ruler of Syracuse in Sicily, and the poet Simonides. Together they consider what a lavish table can tell us about taste and human desire.
 
Their conversation goes something like this.
Simonides suggests that rulers must take greater pleasure in eating and drinking. After all, they enjoy a wider choice than most people, and the dishes served at their tables are finer and more expensive. Surely they enjoy their meals more?
Hiero disagrees. When people look at a ruler’s table, he says, they imagine how much pleasure those dishes would give them. They judge what they see against the meals they usually eat.
 
Most people, Hiero goes on, have a feast to look forward to on a festival day or a special occasion. A ruler has fine food set before him every day. When the festival comes, he misses the pleasure others have already had in looking forward to it.
Simonides still has a question. Once people sit down to eat, surely a fine, expensive dish gives more pleasure than a simple, inexpensive one?
Hiero asks him to consider the sauces and sharp, sour condiments laid out on a ruler’s table. What purpose do they serve? A steady diet of rich food has dulled the ruler’s appetite, and these seasonings are an attempt to stir it again. Someone who comes to the table truly hungry has little need of them.
 
Hiero then makes a particularly telling observation. When a person can have any dish at any time, its appeal gradually fades. Something that comes their way only occasionally is often eaten with far greater relish.
Some two and a half thousand years have passed, yet the difference between the tables of the wealthy and those of ordinary people is still there for us to see. What does the philosophy of taste mean to someone who cannot afford the food they would choose? Their immediate concern is simply to eat their fill.
 
There is pleasure in being welcomed into someone’s home in Hasan Abdal and sharing a meal of okra and lentils. But let us also ask those for whom rising prices have made meat and other favourite foods a rare sight at the table. How do okra and lentils taste to someone who must eat much the same simple meal every day? Does the same philosophy of taste hold for them?
For them, okra and lentils are more than two dishes. They are an expression of patience and gratitude.
 
I hope readers will take my remarks in the spirit in which they are intended. Maryam Nawaz Sharif visited a family to share in the joy of their new home. She sat at their table, ate their food and praised it. In doing so, she honoured her hosts. Other politicians and those in positions of authority would do well to follow her example, visit ordinary citizens and share in their happy occasions.
It would be equally unfair to draw conclusions about the family’s financial circumstances from the simple meal they served. The affection, sincerity and good cheer with which they welcomed their guest reflect a cherished tradition of Pakistani hospitality. The family deserves as much appreciation for the warmth of its welcome as the Chief Minister does for visiting their home and accepting their hospitality.
 
I wrote this column to acknowledge the graciousness of both hosts and guest. What stayed with me as a writer was a remark about how good the okra and lentils tasted. It brought back a conversation Xenophon wrote some two and a half thousand years ago, and I wanted to share it with readers in light of the lives people lead today.
0
Views
25
1

مزید زمینی حقائق

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image